You’ve probably spent years building up your property. There’s the main house, maybe a granny flat your parents moved into, and a shed with power, a concrete slab and a workbench that gets used every weekend. When your home insurance renewal arrives, you’d like to know your sum insured reflects what it could cost to rebuild your property. A professional rebuild cost assessment can help identify whether structures such as granny flats and sheds have been properly accounted for.

This article explains what an insurance replacement valuation actually measures, whether granny flats and sheds are covered, where the common gaps are, and what to check before your next renewal.

What an Insurance Replacement Valuation Measures

An insurance replacement valuation estimates how much it would cost to rebuild your buildings if they were destroyed, using similar materials and a similar standard of construction. It’s a construction cost figure, not a market value.

Replacement cost is not market value

Your property’s market value reflects what a buyer would pay for the land and buildings together, which depends on the suburb, the market and the sale. Replacement cost ignores the land entirely. A house in a high-value suburb might have a market value of $2 million but a replacement cost of $500,000 or less, because insurance only needs to rebuild the structure.

This is one of the most common points of confusion. Insurance doesn’t pay out based on what your home would sell for, so a high market value doesn’t mean your insurance cover is adequate.

What a replacement valuation usually includes

A proper replacement valuation considers:

Some valuations also consider demolition, debris removal and the cost of meeting current council requirements after a loss. Whether these are included depends on the valuation and on your policy’s wording, so it’s worth asking.

Are Granny Flats Covered by Home Insurance?

A granny flat is a separate dwelling on the same block as your main home. In New South Wales it’s usually called a secondary dwelling. Under the state’s planning policy, the floor area is generally capped at 60 square metres, but councils can apply their own rules, and the rules differ in other states. Check your local requirements if you’re planning one.

Here’s the catch: many home insurance policies treat a granny flat differently from the main house. Some policies:

If the granny flat is rented to a tenant, the rules can change again. Landlord policies and residential tenancy arrangements sometimes handle this differently from an owner-occupied policy, so read the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) carefully or ask your broker to confirm.

How to check your policy

Look for phrases such as “outbuildings,” “detached structures,” “other buildings” or “secondary dwellings” in your policy schedule and PDS. If you can’t find a clear answer, ask the insurer directly and get the reply in writing.

Sheds, Garages and Workshops

Sheds are one of the most frequently under-insured parts of a property. They often look inexpensive, but a large shed with a concrete slab, electrical wiring, roller doors and a fitted-out workshop can cost far more to rebuild than most owners expect. Understanding the factors that affect rebuilding costs can help explain why size, materials and construction details make such a difference.

Things that increase the replacement cost include:

Tools, equipment and removable items are usually contents, not buildings, so they’re covered under a separate contents sum insured. Fixed items attached to the structure, such as a built-in workbench bolted to the wall, are normally treated as part of the building. The line between the two can be blurry, so it’s worth checking how your insurer classifies them.

Common Gaps That Lead to Underinsurance

Underinsurance happens when the sum insured is lower than the true cost of rebuilding. This matters because some policies reduce a claim proportionally if the sum insured is too low. Here are the gaps we see most often:

A simple example

Imagine a family with a brick home, a timber-framed granny flat and a large steel shed. The main house is insured for $650,000. The granny flat was built five years ago and sits under a $50,000 outbuildings limit. The shed was never added to the policy. If a storm destroys the granny flat and shed, the family may find the outbuildings limit doesn’t cover the full rebuild, and the shed may not be covered at all. A replacement valuation would show the true figures and identify where the policy needs to change.

If Your Property Is in a Strata or Community Title Scheme

Strata and community title properties follow different insurance rules: NSW community-title insurance valuation requirements include obtaining a qualified valuation of relevant buildings and structures at least once every five years.

In a strata scheme, the owners corporation generally insures the building and common property. In NSW, the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 generally requires owners corporations to insure buildings for their full replacement value, which is why accurate replacement valuations matter so much to strata managers and committees.

Individual lot owners usually need to insure their own improvements, such as internal fit-outs, alterations and any structures that sit within their lot. Some strata schemes also have by-laws about what can be built or added to a lot, and these can affect what’s covered. A shed or garden structure on common property is usually the owners corporation’s responsibility, but a structure built on your lot may not be. If you’re unsure, check the strata plan, the by-laws and the scheme’s insurance certificate, then speak to your strata manager.

Steps to Check Your Cover

  1. Get your policy schedule and PDS. Confirm what the dwelling and outbuildings sums are, and whether any structures are excluded.
  2. List every building on the property. Include granny flats, sheds, garages, carports, studios, pergolas and any other structures that could be damaged.
  3. Note the size and construction of each. Measurements, materials and any fixed fittings all affect the rebuild cost.
  4. Ask whether the valuation is current. If the last valuation is more than a few years old, or if you’ve done major works, it’s worth updating it.
  5. Tell your insurer about changes. New buildings, renovations and rental arrangements should be reported.
  6. Get a replacement valuation if the numbers don’t add up. An independent valuation gives you a defensible figure to compare with your sum insured.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does home insurance cover a granny flat in Australia?
Often, but not always. Many policies cover detached structures under a separate outbuildings limit, and some only cover the main house. Check your PDS and confirm with your insurer in writing.

Is an insurance replacement valuation the same as a market valuation?
No. A replacement valuation estimates the cost to rebuild the structure and ignores the land. A market valuation estimates what the whole property would sell for.

How often should I update my replacement valuation?
There’s no single national rule for homeowners. Many people review their figures every few years and after any major building work. Strata schemes may have their own requirements, so check with your strata manager.

Will my insurer pay less if my sum insured is too low?
It depends on the policy. Some contain underinsurance or average clauses that reduce a claim in proportion to the shortfall. Read the wording carefully or ask your broker to explain it.

Does a replacement valuation include demolition and council costs?
It can, depending on how the valuation is prepared and how your policy handles debris removal and compliance costs. Ask the valuer what’s included and check your policy’s limits for these items.

Can I add a shed or granny flat to my policy after I’ve bought it?
Usually yes, but you’ll generally need to tell the insurer and may need to update the sum insured. Don’t wait for a claim to find out it isn’t covered.

Conclusion

Granny flats and sheds are easy to overlook, but they can represent a large share of your rebuild cost. Check whether your policy covers them under the main dwelling or a separate limit, and make sure the figures reflect today’s construction costs rather than what they cost years ago.

If the numbers look out of date, a replacement valuation is the most reliable way to find out. It’s a practical step that can prevent a shortfall when you need the cover most.

Need help checking your insurance replacement valuation?

AC Valuers specialises in insurance replacement assessments for strata schemes and property owners, and can help you work out whether your granny flat, shed or other buildings are properly reflected in your cover. Call AC Valuers on (02) 9666 1488 to talk through what’s involved and whether an inspection would be useful for your property.